Blogs > Year-End Workers’ Comp Checklist for Staffing Agencies

Year-End Workers’ Comp Checklist for Staffing Agencies

By Bob Thompson on November 18, 2026 workers’ comp insurance for staffing agencies

Underwriters base the price of workers’ comp insurance for staffing agencies on the payroll, claims, and client records in each renewal submission. When those records are out of date, the quote won’t match the agency’s current payroll or claims. Before year-end, staffing agencies and their brokers should check four things: payroll by class code, next year’s payroll estimates, the claim data behind the experience mod, and the status of every open claim. Each review then feeds into a complete renewal submission.

Insurance for Staffing Agencies: What To Review Before Renewal

Each item on the checklist connects to one of two numbers: the payroll your premium starts from, or the experience mod that adjusts it. Let’s start with payroll, since every other calculation builds on it.

Reconcile Payroll by Class Code and State

California’s rating bureau explains that workers’ comp rates apply per $100 of payroll. Each class code carries its own rate, so the premium on a dollar of payroll depends on the code and state you report it under. When a placement is under the wrong code, your premium no longer matches the risk. Depending on the direction of the error, you either overpay at renewal or owe more after an auditor corrects it.

Compare the payroll you paid in each class code and state with the estimates on your current policy. Then fix any class code that no longer matches the work a placement performs, so next year’s estimates start from the right codes before your next premium audit.

T2 Insurance Solutions offers premium audit and filing assistance, plus support with accurate NCCI classifications. Use that support before the audit, while you can still correct your records.

Update Payroll Estimates for January Wage Increases

Once this year’s payroll is under the right codes, the next step is to project next year’s. California and New Jersey both raise their minimum wages on Jan. 1, 2027. For example, California’s statewide rate rises to $17.40 an hour, and New Jersey’s rises to $16.48 an hour for most employees. An agency placing hourly workers at the minimum will report more payroll next year for the same hours worked. Because rates apply per $100 of payroll, more payroll means more premium, even when the rate and mod stay the same.

The wage increase also creates an audit risk. Your policy starts with estimated payroll, and the audit compares that estimate with the payroll you paid. If the estimate leaves out a wage increase, the audit picks up the difference, and you receive an additional premium bill after the policy year ends. Check the scheduled wage changes in every state where you place workers, and build them into next year’s estimates.

Check the Data Behind Your Experience Mod

Payroll sets the base premium, and your experience mod adjusts it. The mod compares your claims history with that of similar businesses and raises or lowers your premium accordingly.

The mod reflects earlier years, not the current one. The calculation generally draws on three policy years of class code, payroll, and claim data, and it skips the most recent year. For a mod that takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, the calculation would use the policy years that started in 2023, 2024, and 2025. The 2026 policy year would be left out. Claim values lock in even earlier. In states such as North Carolina, carriers first value a policy year’s claims 18 months after the policy starts, about six months after that policy year ends. At that valuation, the carrier reports each claim’s paid amount plus its reserve, the money set aside for future payments. A reserve left on a claim that has closed counts as a loss you never paid. The extra loss pushes your mod higher than your claims history supports, and a higher mod raises your premium for the policy term.

Request current loss runs, and compare them with your experience mod worksheet, looking for closed claims that still carry reserves. Correction procedures and timelines vary by state, so send any errors to your broker as soon as you find them. 

Review Every Open Claim

The same reserve math applies to open claims. Each open claim’s reserve is fed to the mod as a loss. Because the mod uses three policy years, a claim from this year will start counting in two years and then stay in the calculation for three renewals. 

Before year-end, confirm three things for every open claim: its current status, the next medical step, and whether the worker can return on modified duty. A claim that closes or whose reserve drops before the next valuation date reports a smaller loss to the mod. 

What Should a Staffing Renewal Submission Include?

Each review on the checklist ends up in one place: the renewal submission. Underwriters price the work your employees perform at client sites, so the submission needs to show the business the agency runs today. Include every client, job duty, and state you added this year. 

T2 works with agencies in light industrial, professional, healthcare, and technical staffing. If you expanded into a new segment, describe those roles in detail, since each placement type carries different hazards and class codes. If you added states, list each one along with the work you place there. 

A complete submission includes:

  • Loss runs: Current, carrier-issued loss runs for each policy year in the experience period so that the underwriter can confirm the claim data behind your mod
  • Mod worksheet: Your current experience mod worksheet, along with any errors you found and reported
  • Payroll detail: Paid and estimated payroll by class code and state, with next year’s wage changes built in
  • Client and job information: A client list with job descriptions that support each class code
  • Program documentation: Written safety, training, and return-to-work procedures that show how the agency controls claim costs

When the package is complete, the underwriter can price the agency from its records. When pieces are missing, the underwriter has to go back to the broker for them, which can push the quote close to the renewal date. If the information doesn’t arrive in time, the underwriter may price the account conservatively or decline to quote. 

Get Your Renewal Submission in Order Before January

Payroll under the right codes, wage estimates that reflect next year, and claim data that matches what you paid give an underwriter what it needs to price your agency fairly. T2 Insurance Solutions helps brokers review the classifications, payroll, and claim data that shape insurance for staffing agencies. If you have a staffing renewal on the calendar, bring the submission to T2 before year-end. We’ll help you find the staffing insurance solutions that fit where the agency stands today.

About Bob Thompson

Bob Thompson is the CEO of T2 Insurance Solutions LLC, a specialized insurance wholesaler focused on workers’ compensation for the staffing industry. With decades of leadership experience, Bob brings deep industry knowledge and a strategic approach to complex insurance challenges. He co-founded T2 to address critical gaps in the market, delivering expert-driven solutions tailored to staffing firms and the brokers who serve them. Backed by a leadership team with over 100 years of combined experience, Bob is committed to building strong partnerships and advancing innovative strategies that help clients navigate the evolving workers’ compensation landscape.

About Jeff Tuisl

 Jeff Tuisl is president and co-founder of T2 Insurance Solutions, a wholesale brokerage firm specializing in workers’ compensation programs for temporary staffing companies and professional employer organizations. With more than 30 years of experience in the property and casualty insurance industry, Tuisl built his career across underwriting and brokerage, including 24 years as a principal at Assurance Agency, a Marsh McLennan Agency, where he grew a national staffing book of more than 500 clients. He holds the CPCU designation and is a graduate of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, based in the Chicago area. 

About T2 Insurance Solutions

T2 Wholesale Insurance Brokers is a reliable expert in workers’ compensation insurance. With a century of combined experience, T2’s founders bring unparalleled insight and understanding to the table. Specializing in catering to the unique demands of workers’ compensation insurance, T2 prides itself on crafting comprehensive, competitive insurance solutions that address the diverse requirements and challenges across all industries.


Related Post

workers’ comp insurance for staffing agencies

The Role of the Staffing Agency in a Workers’ Comp Claim: What Owners Need To Know

The call comes from a client's floor supervisor: one of your workers got hurt on the line an hour ago. In a standard...

Read More
staffing agency workers’ comp insurance

Why Your Staffing Agency’s EMR May Be Higher Than It Should Be

Staffing agency owners often assume their experience modification rate (EMR) reflects only how safe their workplaces are. In practice, a lot of the...

Read More
workers' comp for staffing agencies

What Staffing Agencies Need To Know About Workers’ Comp Audits Before They Happen

A workers' compensation audit is not a red flag. It is a routine check carriers use to confirm that a policy's premium matches...

Read More